Former UN Ambassador Challenges Trump on Chinese Student Enrollment

Former United Nations Ambassador Nikki Haley positioned herself to the right of President Donald Trump on Thursday, warning that his plan to allow 600,000 Chinese students to study in the United States represents a “massive mistake” and a national security threat.

“That would be a huge gift to China and a threat to the United States,” Haley wrote on social media, breaking with the president on an issue that has divided conservatives and raised questions about the administration’s approach to Chinese influence operations.

Here are the facts: Trump first proposed the 600,000 figure in August, immediately triggering alarm bells among conservatives who have spent years warning about Chinese Communist Party espionage at American universities. According to federal data, more than 277,000 Chinese students studied in the United States during the 2023-2024 academic year. The White House later clarified that the 600,000 figure refers to two years’ worth of visas, effectively representing a continuation of current policy rather than a dramatic expansion.

The response from conservatives has been nothing short of remarkable. Many expressed shock that Haley, typically regarded as a more establishment Republican, would stake out ground to Trump’s right on both immigration and China policy.

“I did not have Nikki Haley being to Trump’s right on immigration issues on my 2025 bingo card,” wrote S.A. McCarthy, an editor at The American Spectator magazine.

Conservative analyst Greg Lawson put it bluntly: “I rarely agree with Nikki Haley. I think she is far too much of a throwback to failed George W. Bush era thinking. BUT, on this specific issue, she is right.”

The criticism extends beyond national security concerns to basic economics. Multiple observers questioned the logic of training foreign nationals when America faces a shortage of tech workers. Others pointed to the fundamental problem of supply and demand in higher education: flooding universities with foreign students drives up costs for American families.

“It is insane for the Trump administration to allow 600,000 foreigners into American colleges, not because they are Chinese, but because the cost of college is already too high,” one commentator wrote. “Reduce demand, reduce costs.”

Trump defended the policy Monday, arguing that cutting Chinese student enrollment would devastate American higher education. “We do have a lot of people coming in from China. We always have, China and other countries,” he said. “We also have a massive system of colleges and universities. And if we were to cut that in half, which perhaps makes some people happy, you would have half the colleges in the United States go out of business.”

This argument deserves scrutiny. The president is essentially suggesting that American universities have become dependent on Chinese tuition revenue to remain solvent. If true, that represents a strategic vulnerability, not a reason to continue the policy. Universities that cannot survive without foreign subsidies should either restructure their business models or face market consequences.

The national security implications cannot be ignored. Chinese espionage at American universities is well-documented. The question is whether the economic benefits to higher education institutions outweigh the risks of intellectual property theft and technology transfer to a strategic adversary.

Conservatives now find themselves in an unusual position: agreeing with Nikki Haley while questioning Trump’s judgment on China policy. The debate reveals a fundamental tension within the administration between economic pragmatism and national security hawkishness.

The facts matter here. If the policy merely continues current visa levels, the White House should communicate that clearly. If it represents an expansion, the administration must explain why the benefits justify the risks. What conservatives should not accept is policy justified primarily by the financial needs of bloated university bureaucracies.

Related: Biden Appointee Orders Release of 615 Illegal Immigrants After Chicago Raids