Third World Somalia Just Showed America How to Run Honest Elections

When Somalia Puts Us to Shame

Here’s something that’ll stick in your craw. Somalia, yes that Somalia, the place Americans associate with warlords and instability, now has stricter voter ID requirements than most of the United States. Let that sink in for a moment.

President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud announced last year that only people with national identification cards would be recognized as citizens once their biometric ID program wraps up. Not a driver’s license. Not a utility bill. A proper, biometric national ID card that he calls “the cornerstone of Somali belonging.”

And here’s the kicker. He said it plainly: “It is through identification that one becomes Somali, not through appearance or simply speaking the Somali language.” Imagine an American politician saying something that straightforward about citizenship and identity. The mainstream media would have a collective meltdown.

Somalia has been operating without a centralized identity framework for over 30 years. Three decades of chaos. But even they figured out that secure elections require knowing who’s actually voting. Starting last July, Somali citizens need to present their national IDs to access bank accounts, board domestic flights, and cast ballots.

The country’s got about 20 million people, yet nearly 10 million Somali passports are floating around out there. Many obtained illegally. Fraud on a massive scale. So they’re fixing it with technology and common sense.

Why This Matters Beyond Somalia

Now, I’m not naive. There’s a dark side to comprehensive ID systems, especially in authoritarian hands. Anything that makes it easier for government to track citizens and flip switches to deny services should give freedom-loving Americans pause. That’s legitimate concern, and it’s why we push back against things like digital currencies that governments can control or universal healthcare systems that create dependency.

But here’s the thing. We can acknowledge those risks while still recognizing the absurdity of our current situation. Somalia just held local council elections in Mogadishu for the first time in over 50 years. Residents got to democratically choose their representatives. And you know what we didn’t hear? Mass complaints about voter disenfranchisement because of ID requirements.

Meanwhile, back in the greatest democracy on Earth, we can’t even agree that verifying someone’s identity before they vote is reasonable. Half the country acts like asking for ID is tantamount to Jim Crow. The other half watches places like Somalia implement basic security measures and wonders what happened to American common sense.

The Elephant in Every Voting Booth

Representative Ilhan Omar, who came to America from Somalia as a refugee, has called voter ID laws “voter suppression.” Think about that irony. Her home country just implemented a “one person, one vote” system that requires voter ID cards, but she claims the same requirement here somehow prevents people from participating in democracy.

Which is it? Are Somalis more capable of obtaining identification than Americans? Or is this entire argument built on something other than genuine concern for voter access?

Every functional society needs to know who its citizens are. That’s not controversial in most of the world. You can’t board a plane without ID. Can’t open a bank account. Can’t buy alcohol or cigarettes. Can’t rent a car or get a hotel room. But suggesting you should prove who you are before participating in the sacred act of choosing leaders? Suddenly that’s a bridge too far.

Somalia’s president said their biometric IDs would help counter widespread passport fraud and enhance national security. Those are legitimate government functions that even small-government conservatives can support. Knowing who’s in your country and preventing fraud isn’t oppression. It’s basic administration.

What We Can Learn Without Losing Ourselves

I’m not suggesting America adopt Somalia’s system wholesale. Our founding principles of limited government and individual liberty matter. The balance between security and freedom is delicate, and we should always err on the side of freedom.

But we’ve swung so far in the direction of accessibility without verification that we’ve made election integrity nearly impossible to guarantee. And when you can’t guarantee integrity, you erode trust. When trust erodes, democracy itself becomes fragile.

The solution isn’t complicated. Free voter ID programs for anyone who needs one. Mobile units that go to rural areas and underserved communities. Make the ID easy to get but mandatory to vote. Problem solved.

Instead, we’ve turned this into another culture war battle where common sense gets sacrificed on the altar of political tribalism. One side screams about fraud. The other screams about suppression. And Somalia, of all places, just quietly implemented a system that addresses both concerns.

That should embarrass us. A nation that’s been torn apart by civil war, terrorism, and instability for decades just figured out something we apparently can’t. They decided election security matters more than political posturing.

Maybe it’s time we did the same.

Related: A Planned Parenthood Director Walked Away and Now She’s Ready to Tell Everything