There’s a moment when a joke stops being funny and starts revealing something darker about the person telling it. Jimmy Kimmel found that moment Thursday night on his ABC show, and by Saturday evening, reality had a way of making his comedy look less like satire and more like something we should’ve been paying closer attention to all along.
During his broadcast, Kimmel decided to stage his own mock White House Correspondents’ Dinner. You know, because the real president won’t attend his roasting session, so naturally the solution is to create your own fantasy version where you get to say whatever you want without consequences. He ran through the usual targets with his one-liners, hitting Trump, Vance, Miller. Standard late-night fare for a host who’s made hating this administration his entire brand. But then he turned his attention to First Lady Melania Trump.
“And of course, our first lady, Melania, is here. Look at her. So beautiful. Mrs. Trump, you have a glow like an expectant widow,” Kimmel said to applause and laughter from his studio audience.
An expectant widow. Let that sink in for a second. He’s fantasizing about the president’s death, dressing it up as comedy, and a room full of people clapped for it. This wasn’t some edgy underground comedy club at two in the morning. This was Disney-owned ABC, broadcast into millions of American homes during prime time.
The timing makes it worse. Just days after Kimmel’s little fantasy aired, 31-year-old Cole Tomas Allen of Torrance, California, allegedly charged through a metal detector at the actual White House Correspondents’ Dinner and shot a Secret Service agent in the chest before being tackled and arrested. The agent survived, thank God, but we’re talking about the third assassination attempt against this president. The third time someone has tried to kill Donald Trump, and here’s a major network comedian joking about his death less than 48 hours before another lunatic makes his move.
Allen wasn’t some random disturbed individual acting in a vacuum either. He was a Kamala Harris donor. According to a senior White House official, he wrote a manifesto and attended a left-wing No King’s protest. During an interview Sunday morning, President Trump called him “a sick guy” and noted that Allen’s manifesto revealed a hatred for Christians. “When you read his manifesto, he hates Christians, that’s one thing for sure. He hates Christians, the hatred. And I think his sister, or his brother, actually was complaining about it. They were even complaining to law enforcement. So he was a very troubled guy,” Trump said.
Now I’m not saying Jimmy Kimmel pulled the trigger. That’s not how this works. But we live in a media environment where the left has spent years telling Americans that Trump is Hitler, that he’s an existential threat to democracy, that he’s going to destroy the country. They’ve created a permission structure for violence by dehumanizing this president at every turn. And when you’ve got a late-night comedian on a major network joking about the First Lady becoming a widow, you’re adding fuel to a fire that’s already burned too hot.
This isn’t Kimmel’s first rodeo with dangerous rhetoric either. The host found himself suspended last year after telling his ABC audience that it was a MAGA supporter who assassinated Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk. Except Kirk wasn’t assassinated. He’s alive. Kimmel just made it up, broadcast it as fact, and faced consequences only after the damage was done.
There’s supposed to be a line between political commentary and incitement. Between satire and something darker. Kimmel keeps dancing on that line, and every time something terrible happens, we’re supposed to pretend there’s no connection between the cultural atmosphere these entertainers create and the actions of disturbed individuals who take the message seriously.
Comedy has always pushed boundaries. Good comedy should make people uncomfortable sometimes. But there’s a difference between speaking truth to power and fantasizing about political violence on national television. When three separate people have tried to kill the president, maybe joking about his wife becoming a widow isn’t the bold comedic stance Kimmel thinks it is. Maybe it’s just reckless.
The studio audience laughed. That’s what haunts me about this whole thing. Regular people, sitting in that room, heard a joke about the president dying and his wife mourning him, and they clapped. They thought it was funny. That’s where we are as a country right now, and it should terrify anyone who cares about basic decency regardless of political affiliation.
Kimmel will face no real consequences for this. ABC won’t pull his show. Advertisers won’t flee. He’ll probably make another joke about it next week, playing the victim card about how conservatives can’t take a joke. But somewhere out there, another disturbed individual is watching, absorbing the message that this president deserves whatever happens to him. And the cycle continues.
Related: Senate Republicans Are About to Learn Why House Conservatives Don’t Do Skinny Anything