Carmen Lizet Puch should be alive today. She should be reading bedtime stories to her 3-year-old daughter, planning weekend trips, worrying about ordinary things like preschool enrollment and grocery bills. Instead, she’s dead. Murdered in a park in Great Falls, Virginia, allegedly by a man who never should have been in this country to begin with.
The details are brutal. Alexis Antonio Cedillos-Campos, an illegal alien from El Salvador, reportedly confessed to everything. Police say he left his restaurant job in the early morning hours of August 17 carrying a knife, gloves, and a bottle filled with gasoline he’d siphoned from his motorcycle. He went to that park with Carmen, his coworker. What happened next reads like a horror film. Stabbed to death, then doused with gasoline and set on fire. A human being reduced to a crime scene because our government couldn’t be bothered to enforce the most basic function of a sovereign nation.
Here’s what really stings. Cedillos-Campos crossed into El Paso, Texas, in April. That means he walked across during the final months of the Biden administration, when the border wasn’t just porous but practically welcoming. Catch and release wasn’t a policy failure under Biden. It was the policy, period. Hundreds of thousands of people with zero vetting, zero accountability, just waved through and scattered across America like confetti.
You know what gets me? The GoFundMe page for Carmen’s daughter describes her as someone with a “gentle spirit” who was “always looking out for others.” She’d moved from New Jersey, working hard to build something better for her little girl. That’s the American story we’re supposed to celebrate, right? Hard work, sacrifice, doing everything for your kid. Carmen was living that story until someone our government let in decided to end it.
We’re told that questioning these outcomes makes us heartless or xenophobic. That’s garbage. Wanting secure borders isn’t about hate. It’s about basic responsibility. Every nation on Earth controls who enters. That’s not controversial anywhere except in American newsrooms and faculty lounges. When you abandon that principle, you get predictable results. Carmen Puch is one of those results.
The same people who lecture us about compassion never seem to have much for the American victims of their policies. They’ll wring their hands about conditions in Central America while ignoring the mother of a toddler who got burned alive in Virginia. The math doesn’t work. Compassion that extends to everyone except your own citizens isn’t compassion. It’s cowardice dressed up in moral superiority.
Think about Carmen’s daughter. She’s three years old. She won’t remember much about her mother as she grows up. Maybe fragments, feelings, the ghost of a voice. Someone will have to explain to her one day why mommy never came home. What do you say? How do you make that make sense? You can’t, because it doesn’t make sense. It was preventable. Completely, utterly preventable.
Fairfax County police did their job. They arrested Cedillos-Campos and he allegedly confessed. The system worked after the crime. But the system failed catastrophically before it. That’s the pattern we keep seeing. Local law enforcement cleaning up messes that federal immigration policy created. It’s backwards and it’s deadly.
Carmen’s friends remember her kindness and work ethic. They’re raising money for her daughter because that’s what decent people do when tragedy strikes. But charity can’t fix this. Only serious policy can. Secure the border. Enforce the law. Protect Americans first. These aren’t radical ideas. They’re the bare minimum we should expect from our government.
Related: Rep Brandon Gill Takes Aim at McKinsey Over Workplace Diversity Reports