Here are the facts. Twenty-four hours after standing at a White House podium explaining why the Federal Aviation Administration grounded every plane in America, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin was sitting in Baton Rouge watching LSU play Texas. He flew there on a government plane while American travelers were still dealing with the cascading effects of a massive systems failure that disrupted more than 1.5 million people.
Let us be clear about what happened here. On Friday, Mullin appeared alongside Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy to inform the nation that aging FAA infrastructure had been overwhelmed by new technology patches, causing a roughly five-hour ground stop. The ripple effects continued through Monday. By Saturday, Mullin was attending not one but two college football games, including the LSU matchup where he reportedly spent time in the private box of Ben Bordelon, CEO of Bollinger Shipyards.
Now, Bollinger just happens to hold a $2.2 billion Coast Guard contract to build four icebreaking ships. The Coast Guard falls under the Department of Homeland Security. Perhaps this is entirely coincidental. Perhaps there is a perfectly reasonable explanation for why the DHS Secretary attended a football game in a private box belonging to a CEO whose company holds billions in government contracts under his purview.
The Department of Homeland Security insists Mullin paid for the travel expenses himself and that he is legally required to fly on government aircraft for security and continuity of government purposes. This is technically accurate. Cabinet secretaries cannot fly commercial due to legitimate security concerns and the need for secure communications. The question is not whether he broke the law. The question is whether this demonstrates appropriate judgment.
Consider the optics. American travelers are stranded in airports across the country. Families miss connections. Business travelers lose crucial meetings. The flying public watches in real time as the supposedly modernized FAA infrastructure crumbles under the weight of what amounts to a software update gone wrong. And the Homeland Security Secretary, fresh off explaining this debacle to the nation, decides the proper course of action is attending college football games.
The DHS spokesperson stated that Mullin "abides by all ethics requirements." This is the standard Washington response. It translates to: technically legal, therefore beyond criticism. But ethics requirements represent the bare minimum threshold for conduct, not the aspirational standard Americans should expect from cabinet officials during a transportation crisis.
Mullin began his Saturday at the Coast Guard Academy versus U.S. Merchant Marine Academy game in Washington, then flew to Louisiana for the LSU game. One could argue the Coast Guard Academy game falls within his official duties, given DHS oversight. The LSU game in a contractor’s private box is harder to justify as essential government business during an ongoing crisis.
The reality is this: government officials operate under different rules than ordinary Americans. They fly on government planes while telling the rest of us that aging infrastructure is simply overwhelming. They attend football games in corporate boxes while travelers sleep on airport floors. And they assure us everything is above board because they checked the right boxes and followed the minimum ethics guidelines.
None of this is illegal. All of it looks terrible. And terrible optics during a crisis reflect poor judgment, regardless of what the ethics lawyers say.
Related: Foreign Student Enrollment Plummets as Federal Government Closes Visa Loopholes
