Court Allows New York to Continue Blocking ICE Access to Illegal Immigrant Driving Records

A federal judge has ruled against the Trump administration’s legal challenge to New York’s Green Light Law, allowing the state to continue issuing driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants while simultaneously blocking federal immigration enforcement from accessing their records. Let us be clear about what this means: a state is actively obstructing federal law enforcement while providing benefits to those who violated federal immigration law to enter the country.

U.S. District Judge Anne M. Nardacci determined that the Justice Department failed to prove that New York’s law sought to invalidate federal law or unlawfully discriminated against the federal government. The ruling represents a significant setback for the administration’s efforts to enforce immigration law in sanctuary jurisdictions.

The facts here are straightforward. The Green Light Law, formally known as the Driver’s License Access and Privacy Act, permits individuals without valid Social Security numbers to obtain driver’s licenses using alternative identification, including foreign passports and driver’s licenses from other countries. More troubling, the law explicitly prevents federal immigration agents from accessing these illegal immigrants’ criminal driving records during traffic stops.

When U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi announced the lawsuit in February against Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James, she correctly identified the core issue: New York was prioritizing illegal aliens over American citizens and law enforcement. The administration argued that the law constituted “a frontal assault on the federal immigration laws, and the federal authorities that administer them.”

The lawsuit specifically challenged a provision requiring New York’s DMV commissioner to notify illegal immigrants when federal immigration agencies request their information. This is not merely bureaucratic procedure; it is active interference with federal law enforcement operations.

Judge Nardacci wrote that her role was not to evaluate the desirability of the policy but to determine whether the Trump administration proved the statute violates the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause, which establishes federal law as supreme over state law. According to her ruling, the administration “failed to state such a claim.”

This reasoning is problematic. The Constitution grants the federal government exclusive authority over immigration and naturalization. When a state creates a system that actively obstructs federal immigration enforcement, it is difficult to see how this does not conflict with federal supremacy.

New York officials predictably celebrated the decision. Attorney General James stated, “As I said from the start, our laws protect the rights of all New Yorkers and keep our communities safe.” This claim requires scrutiny. Illegal immigrants, by definition, do not have a right to be in the country. Protecting those who violated federal law while simultaneously blocking federal agents from enforcing that law does not keep communities safe; it undermines the rule of law.

The state argues the law improves road safety by ensuring people who would drive anyway can obtain licenses and insurance. This argument ignores the obvious solution: enforcing immigration law and removing those who entered illegally, rather than creating parallel systems that reward illegal presence.

This case represents a broader conflict between sanctuary jurisdictions and federal immigration enforcement. The timing is particularly notable, coming as a Border Patrol agent was recently killed on the Northern Border, a stark reminder that immigration enforcement is not merely administrative but involves real security concerns.

The question remains whether the Trump administration will appeal this decision. Given the constitutional issues at stake and the precedent this sets for state obstruction of federal law enforcement, an appeal seems likely and necessary.

Related: Supreme Court Splits on National Guard Deployment as Chicago Descends Into Chaos