So let me get this straight. While Americans were losing their jobs, their businesses, and in some cases their loved ones, a senior advisor to the nation’s top health official was allegedly playing hide-and-seek with emails about the origins of the virus that upended our lives. David Morens, who spent years as Anthony Fauci’s trusted lieutenant at the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, now faces federal charges for allegedly using his personal email to dodge transparency laws. The Justice Department isn’t mincing words here.

The indictment unsealed Tuesday tells a story that should make every taxpayer’s blood boil. Prosecutors say Morens, now 78, deliberately moved conversations off government systems to keep them away from Freedom of Information Act requests. You know what that means? When journalists and concerned citizens tried to find out what our government knew about COVID-19 and when they knew it, these guys were allegedly making sure those answers stayed buried in private inboxes.

This isn’t just about bureaucratic procedure. The communications Morens allegedly hid involved discussions about a research grant connected to the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China. That’s the same lab at the center of the debate over whether COVID-19 leaked from a research facility rather than jumping naturally from animals to humans. The grant got terminated once people started asking hard questions, but by then the damage was done. Millions dead worldwide. Economies wrecked. Kids locked out of schools for years.

The indictment gets worse. Federal prosecutors claim Morens was accepting gifts from a collaborator, including wine and fancy meals. Then he allegedly contributed to a scientific publication pushing the natural origin theory for the virus. Convenient timing, right? Nothing says objective science quite like getting wined and dined while helping shape the narrative that your benefactor prefers.

Here’s the thing about transparency in government. It’s not some abstract principle dreamed up by civics teachers. It’s the bedrock of accountability in a free society. When officials can hide their communications from the public, they’re not public servants anymore. They’re just servants of their own interests and the interests of whoever they’re protecting. The Founders understood this. They built a system designed to keep power in check precisely because they knew human nature tends toward self-preservation over truth.

Morens allegedly played a behind-the-scenes role feeding information to senior agency leadership, who then briefed the White House, Congress, and the American people during the pandemic. Think about that chain of communication for a second. If the information going in was filtered, manipulated, or incomplete, then everything that came out the other end was compromised too. Every policy decision. Every mandate. Every reassurance that our leaders had things under control.

The American people deserved better than this. We deserved straight answers about where this virus came from and whether our own tax dollars might have funded research that contributed to the pandemic. Instead, we got carefully managed messaging and allegedly a deliberate effort to keep crucial information hidden from public view. That’s not how you build trust. That’s how you destroy it.

This indictment represents more than just one man’s alleged misconduct. It’s a window into how deeply the rot can spread when institutions prioritize narrative control over honest transparency. Limited government isn’t just a conservative talking point. It’s a safeguard against exactly this kind of behavior.

Related: Kenyatta Proposes Ban That Wouldn’t Have Stopped the Attack He’s Citing