New York’s New Mayor Wants Credit for Fixing Problems He Helped Create

Bernie Sanders thinks Zohran Mamdani is a fiscal genius. That should tell you everything you need to know.

This week, America’s favorite democratic socialist stood up to applaud New York City’s new mayor for supposedly inheriting a massive budget deficit and magically erasing it while still cranking up spending. Sanders gushed about it like a proud father watching his kid graduate from socialist summer camp. The problem? Nobody’s bothering to look under the hood of this supposed miracle, and there’s a reason for that. What you find there isn’t pretty.

Let’s talk about what actually happened here. Mamdani announced back in January, with all the theatrical alarm of someone discovering fire for the first time, that New York City faced a budget crisis. Shocking news, except state officials had been waving red flags about this exact problem for months. The city had been spending more than it earned for four straight years. Four years. That’s not an inheritance problem. That’s a spending addiction.

And here’s the kicker. There wasn’t some economic catastrophe or revenue collapse causing this mess. The money coming in was fine. The problem was exclusively about how much the city was shoveling out the door. We’re talking about systemwide cost explosions across the board. Take the housing voucher program that somehow quadrupled to nearly two billion dollars in just four years. You read that right. Quadrupled.

Then there’s this beautiful piece of legislative genius called the class size mandate. The state decided New York City needed to hire more teachers, which sounds great until you realize it’s going to cost the city close to a billion dollars every single year. And guess who supported that mandate when he was an assemblyman? That’s right, Mamdani himself. So he helped create a billion dollar problem and now wants applause for dealing with the consequences.

This is the part that really gets me. Politicians create their own crises through feel good legislation that sounds wonderful in press releases, then act surprised when the bills come due. It’s like maxing out your credit cards buying everyone drinks at the bar, then claiming you’re a financial wizard when you figure out how to make the minimum payment. Except in this case, it’s taxpayer money and the bar tab is a hundred and twenty five billion dollars.

The whole situation reminds me of something my grandfather used to say about people who solve problems they created. He had a more colorful way of putting it, but the essence was this: you don’t get credit for putting out fires you started yourself.

What bothers me most isn’t even the spending itself. Cities need services. Teachers matter. Housing assistance can be crucial for families struggling to make it. But there’s this fundamental dishonesty in how progressive politicians approach these issues. They promise the moon, pass expensive mandates, expand programs without considering long term costs, and then act like victims of circumstance when reality shows up with an invoice.

You know what actual fiscal responsibility looks like? It’s making hard choices before you’re forced to make them. It’s saying no to programs you can’t afford, even when they sound compassionate. It’s understanding that every dollar you spend came from someone who worked for it, and treating that money with respect.

Instead, we get this shell game where politicians boost spending, call it investment, and then scramble to balance books through accounting gymnastics that would make Enron blush. And the media cheerleaders, led by people like Sanders, celebrate it as visionary leadership.

New York City deserves better than this. Its taxpayers certainly do. Real leadership would mean admitting past mistakes, cutting programs that don’t work, and building a sustainable budget based on what the city can actually afford. Not what sounds good in a campaign speech.

But that kind of honesty doesn’t get you praise from Bernie Sanders. And maybe that’s exactly the point.

Related: Your Job Went to an H-1B Holder and Here’s Why Nobody Stopped It