There’s something almost impressive about the sheer audacity of Chris Murphy. The Connecticut senator, apparently auditioning for Chuck Schumer’s job, recently stood before a crowd at Judson Memorial Church in New York City and casually dismissed 77 million Americans as ignorant rubes who “actually don’t know much.” Not misinformed. Not misguided. Just plain stupid.
This is the same guy who’s been touring the country promoting his book about rebuilding community and finding common ground. You know what? Maybe start by not calling half the country brain-dead.
Murphy’s comments came during what I’m sure he thought was a friendly audience, the kind of room where everyone nods along when you trash Fox News and pretend MSNBC is the voice of objective truth. When someone sarcastically mentioned that Trump voters don’t watch certain networks, Murphy piled on. He claimed there are sources “even further rigged than Fox, more in the tank for Trump.” The implication is clear. If you voted for Donald Trump, you’re either willfully ignorant or hopelessly trapped in an information bubble. Unlike Murphy and his enlightened friends, of course.
Here’s the thing about this kind of condescension. It’s not just offensive. It’s politically suicidal. Democrats have spent years wondering why working-class Americans keep drifting away from their party. Maybe it’s because those voters can smell contempt from a mile away. When you tell someone they’re too dumb to understand what’s good for them, they tend not to vote for you. Shocking, I know.
Murphy didn’t stop there though. During a May appearance on The View, he described the MAGA movement as a “divisive, hateful community.” He acknowledged that Trump has built something real, a place where people find belonging and purpose. Then he immediately poisoned that admission by slapping the “hateful” label on it. It’s the classic move of someone who understands the problem intellectually but can’t help revealing his disdain emotionally.
The irony gets thicker. Murphy’s book is supposedly about addressing the loneliness epidemic, about how our economy and democracy have been rigged against ordinary people. Those are legitimate concerns. Millions of Americans feel abandoned by institutions that once served them. Their communities have been hollowed out. Their kids are struggling. They’re looking for answers and finding precious few from the political class.
And what does Murphy offer? Lectures about how they’re consuming the wrong media. Suggestions that they need better information sources, preferably ones approved by coastal elites who’ve never set foot in a Pennsylvania steel town or an Ohio factory. This is the definition of missing the point.
Think about what he’s really saying here. Trump voters aren’t making informed choices based on different values or priorities. They’re just confused. They haven’t heard “the real story.” If only they’d turn off Fox News and tune into whatever Murphy considers legitimate journalism, they’d see the light and vote Democrat. It’s patronizing garbage dressed up as concern.
Murphy even traveled overseas earlier this year to tell foreigners that America is experiencing “the most significant threat to democracy since the Civil War.” He stood at some global progressive conference and announced that Trump is trying to end democracy itself. This from a sitting senator who just insulted tens of millions of his own constituents for exercising their democratic right to vote for someone he doesn’t like.
The latest polling shows that only 26 percent of voters feel satisfied with the Democrat Party. You think maybe that number has something to do with this attitude? When your party’s rising stars spend their time calling voters ignorant and hateful, when they jet off to international conferences to badmouth their own country, when they write books about unity while dripping with contempt, people notice.
Republicans aren’t perfect. Far from it. But at least most of us start from the assumption that voters are capable of making rational decisions based on their own interests and values. We don’t need to rescue them from their own ignorance. We trust them to evaluate the evidence and choose accordingly.
Murphy represents everything wrong with modern progressive politics. The smug certainty. The inability to imagine that reasonable people might disagree. The conviction that if you just explain things slowly enough, everyone will eventually agree with you. It’s exhausting and it’s exactly why Democrats keep losing ground with the very people they claim to champion.
Maybe instead of touring bookstores and telling audiences how ignorant Trump voters are, Murphy should actually talk to some of them. Not at them. With them. He might discover they know plenty about what’s happening in their own lives, their own communities, their own country. They might just have different conclusions than he does. That’s called democracy, senator. You should try it sometime.
Related: Mikie Sherrill Can’t Get Past the Front Door at Newark Detention Center