Sheriff Leading 17 Counties Against Maryland Calls Sanctuary Policy Stupidity at Its Best

Sheriff Jeffrey Gahler of Harford County isn’t mincing words anymore, and honestly, why should he? When two women in your jurisdiction get murdered by illegal immigrants within a year of each other, you tend to lose patience with politicians who think good intentions matter more than results. Rachel Morin and Kayla Hamilton are dead. Those are names, not statistics. And Gahler is leading 17 of Maryland’s 24 counties in a lawsuit that’s basically saying what plenty of Americans already think: sanctuary laws are getting people killed.

The sheriff told Congress something that should be obvious to anyone who remembers September 11, 2001. We learned a brutal lesson that day about what happens when law enforcement agencies don’t talk to each other. Information silos cost lives. The 9/11 Commission made that crystal clear. Yet here we are, nearly a quarter century later, and Maryland’s legislature decided it’s somehow progressive to ban local cops from communicating with federal immigration authorities. Gahler called it “stupidity at its best,” and you’d be hard pressed to find a better description.

Governor Wes Moore signed legislation earlier this year that essentially handcuffs local law enforcement. The so-called Community Trust Act sounds nice, doesn’t it? Who could be against community trust? But strip away the feel-good branding and you’ve got a law that prohibits police from asking about immigration status, from detaining suspects to investigate citizenship, from even notifying ICE that they’ve got someone in custody unless a court specifically orders them to do so. That last part is critical. An ICE detainer used to be enough. Now it takes a court order, which means more bureaucracy, more delays, and more opportunities for dangerous people to slip through the cracks.

The logic behind these sanctuary policies always circles back to the same talking points. Democrats argue that working with ICE somehow drains local resources or makes immigrant communities afraid to report crimes. But Gahler pushed back on that narrative when Texas Representative Brandon Gill asked him directly. Should petty criminals who are here illegally be removed from the country? “That’s 100% what I believe,” Gahler answered. No hedging, no political calculation. Just a straightforward answer from someone who deals with the consequences of these policies every single day.

Here’s what the sanctuary crowd never wants to address. When you limit cooperation between local and federal law enforcement, you’re not just protecting people who overstayed a visa and are working hard to build a better life. You’re also protecting criminals who have no business being in this country in the first place. Harford County learned this the hard way. So did the families of Rachel Morin and Kayla Hamilton.

The restrictions Maryland imposed aren’t theoretical concerns for sheriffs like Gahler. They’re operational nightmares. His deputies now have to release people they believe pose a genuine danger rather than hold them for federal authorities. Think about that for a second. A deputy, trained and experienced, looks at someone and thinks this person is dangerous. But state law says release them anyway because the paperwork isn’t exactly right or because ICE didn’t jump through the proper hoops fast enough.

You know what’s really telling? Seventeen counties signed onto this lawsuit. That’s more than two thirds of Maryland’s counties saying the state government has gone too far. These aren’t right-wing activists or political operatives. They’re elected sheriffs who understand their communities and who’ve watched sanctuary policies create preventable tragedies.

State Senator Clarence Lam authored the Community Trust Act and presumably thinks he’s done something noble. Governor Moore let it become law and probably feels good about himself too. But noble intentions don’t bring Rachel Morin or Kayla Hamilton back. They don’t comfort families destroyed by violence that didn’t have to happen. And they certainly don’t honor the lessons we supposedly learned on September 11 about the importance of information sharing between law enforcement agencies.

The political class in Annapolis seems determined to ignore reality in favor of ideology. They’ve decided that signaling the right values matters more than protecting their constituents. Meanwhile, sheriffs like Gahler are left picking up the pieces and explaining to grieving families why the state tied their hands. It’s infuriating and it’s wrong, and these lawsuits represent what happens when local officials finally say enough is enough.

Related: Trump Says He’ll Be America’s Final Republican President Without Voter ID