Blue State Governors Miss the Point on TPS While American Workers Pay the Price

The Supreme Court handed down two common sense immigration rulings Thursday, and you’d think the justices had personally kicked down the doors of every sanctuary city in America based on the hysterical response from blue state governors.

Here’s what actually happened. In a 6-3 decision, the Court ruled that Haitian and Syrian nationals with Temporary Protected Status can’t run to federal courts to delay the revocation of their legal status while they challenge administration policies. In plain English, temporary means temporary. The word itself contains the answer. This isn’t some radical reinterpretation of law. It’s reading comprehension.

The second ruling said migrants turned away at the southern border before entering the United States aren’t entitled to apply for asylum. Again, this is basic stuff. You don’t get to claim the benefits of being inside a country when you’re still outside it. But apparently stating obvious truths makes you a villain in 2025.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul rushed to a press conference to announce her state would fight back by designating “sensitive locations” to block ICE agents and banning masks for immigration enforcers. “This is New York. We fight back,” she declared, as if enforcing federal immigration law was somehow an invasion of sovereign territory. Last I checked, New York was still part of the United States, which means federal law applies there too. The Constitution doesn’t have a carve out for states that really, really disagree with the president.

You know what’s rich about all this? These same leaders who scream about defending immigrants were nowhere to be found when working class Americans in their states struggled with wage suppression from illegal labor competition. They weren’t holding press conferences about that crisis.

New York City Public Advocate Jumaane Williams went further off the rails, accusing the Trump administration of operating with a “White supremacist lens” and embracing “fascist rules.” This is the go-to playbook now. Can’t win the argument on merits? Just yell racism and fascism until everyone’s too exhausted to continue the conversation.

Justice Elena Kagan’s dissent claimed evidence of “racial animus” motivated the TPS revocation for Haitians. But here’s the thing about temporary protected status. It was never meant to be permanent residency through the back door. These protections were designed for genuine emergencies, not as an indefinite immigration program that bypasses the legal process millions of people follow correctly.

The timing matters here too. We’re watching a healthcare system in certain regions strain under the weight of providing services to populations that entered illegally or overstayed temporary protections. At least one House Republican broke ranks over concerns about a looming healthcare crisis. That’s a legitimate worry, not xenophobia.

The real story isn’t about compassion versus cruelty. It’s about the rule of law versus selective enforcement based on political preferences. Every country on earth controls its borders and determines who gets to stay. Somehow America doing the same thing is treated as moral catastrophe by people who lock their own doors at night.

Traditional American generosity toward immigrants works when there’s an orderly system everyone respects. It breaks down when that system becomes optional, enforced only when convenient for one political party. The Supreme Court just reminded everyone that temporary actually means something, that borders actually exist, and that federal law applies even in states that wish it didn’t.

The governors can hold all the press conferences they want. They can designate sensitive locations and make bold declarations. But at the end of the day, they’re public officials sworn to uphold laws they don’t get to cherry pick. That’s not fascism. That’s called a constitutional republic, and it’s worked pretty well for a couple centuries now.

Related: Joy Behar Just Confused Your Local Fire Department With Venezuela