Let’s talk about Hakeem Jeffries and his newfound passion for affordable gasoline. The House Minority Leader spent Friday wringing his hands on social media about gas hitting $4.55 per gallon, asking if this is what the golden age in America looks like. It’s a fair question, honestly. Except Jeffries has zero credibility to ask it.

Four years ago, when Americans were bleeding money at the pump under Joe Biden, this same man told Republicans to stop playing politics with gas prices. You heard that right. Don’t politicize the pain, he said. Show some decorum. Have some class. Now he’s doing exactly what he condemned, and apparently we’re all supposed to pretend we don’t notice.

This is the kind of memory-holing that drives regular people crazy. The rules change depending on who’s sitting in the Oval Office. When your guy is president, economic hardship is complex and nuanced and definitely not his fault. When the other team’s in charge, every cent at the pump is a moral failing and proof of incompetence.

The current spike stems from real problems. The war with Iran has disrupted oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz, that critical chokepoint where roughly a fifth of the world’s petroleum passes through. The Trump administration’s trying to end the conflict, working diplomatic channels while a month-old ceasefire mostly holds. These things take time. You can’t snap your fingers and fix Middle Eastern instability, no matter how much we’d all like that option.

But Jeffries sees an opening. Democrats lost the House, and he’s hunting for any weapon to win it back in November. Voter frustration over gas prices is real, tangible, something people feel every time they fill up. It’s smart politics in the most cynical sense. It’s also transparently dishonest when you consider his track record.

The conservative view here isn’t complicated. We believe in consistency. If high gas prices weren’t Biden’s fault when global markets went haywire, then Trump shouldn’t get sole blame for a war-induced spike either. The president doesn’t control everything, despite what both parties claim when it suits them. Free markets respond to supply and demand, to geopolitical chaos, to forces beyond any single leader’s reach.

What grates isn’t just the hypocrisy. It’s the assumption that Americans won’t remember. That we’re goldfish swimming in circles, incapable of recalling what these same politicians said last year or the year before. Jeffries counted on our amnesia, and he’s not alone. Both parties do this dance, though Democrats seem particularly shameless about it lately.

The Iran situation deserves serious attention. Colonel Joe Buccino, former CENTCOM communications director, notes that Iran has softened its stance on uranium stockpiles in response to U.S. peace proposals. That’s progress, however tentative. Ending this conflict matters more than scoring cheap political points, but apparently that’s a minority opinion in Washington.

Republicans need to hammer this contradiction relentlessly. Not because gas prices are entirely Trump’s doing or entirely not his doing, but because voters deserve leaders who maintain basic intellectual honesty. If you’re going to criticize, own the fact that you defended the same problem under different management. Otherwise, you’re just noise.

The golden age comment is revealing too. Jeffries is mocking Trump’s rhetoric, trying to turn campaign promises into punchlines. Fair enough. Politicians should be held accountable for their promises. But accountability cuts both ways, and Jeffries has offered nothing except opportunistic finger-pointing while his party spent years telling us inflation was transitory and gas prices were Putin’s fault and anyway, maybe you should buy an electric car.

Americans aren’t stupid. We notice the double standard. We see who changes their tune depending on which way the political wind blows. And come November, maybe Jeffries will discover that voters remember more than he thinks.

Related: Wes Moore Just Told America He’d Let His 14-Year-Old Son Transition and the Backlash Is Deserved